Hatchet jobs, fights, and one very divisive song: Razorlight’s Johnny Borrell on making indie’s most notorious second album

Twenty years ago, one song would become the scapegoat for the implosion of British guitar music, the death knell for a generation’s worth of bands whose sole mission seemed to be to make it into the pages of NME. “I think you can kind of say that in 2006, at the start of this [song], music was in quite an interesting place,” Johnny Borrell said in 2016. “Then three-and-a-half minutes later it’s f***ed.”

The Razorlight frontman was, in fact, talking about his band’s own hit single, “Before I Fall to Pieces”. Featured on their second album, the self-titled Razorlight, the jangling guitar track was branded by Borrell as the catalyst for what we now refer to as “landfill indie”, that heady scene of sticky dancefloors, sweaty side-fringes and jeans so skinny they cut off your circulation. “I think the second Razorlight album definitely opened the way for a flood of mediocrity in UK music,” he declared.

“Landfill indie” was a disdainful term coined in The Word by journalist Andrew Harrison in 2008. But two years earlier, in the summer of 2006, British bands ruled the roost: Arctic Monkeys had already set the world alight with their debut, Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not, Muse were about to top the charts again with Black Holes and Revelations, and Coldplay were concluding their huge Twisted Logic Tour off the back of two major Brit awards for their third album, X&Y . Skinny jeans, scarves and slogan T-shirts (all from Topshop) were in, as was smudged eyeliner and the side fringe; Camden boozer the Hawley Arms was the place to be, especially when Amy Winehouse was holding court.

The Libertines had split in 2004, but Pete Doherty was still a tabloid fixture thanks to his chaotic personal life. And Razorlight had the biggest album of their career, thanks in part to hit singles like “In the Morning”, “America” and, yes, “Before I Fall to Pieces”. Borrell is revisiting the album as it celebrates its 20th anniversary.

Not just the music, but all of it – the mixed reception (NME gave it 8/10 but also nominated it for Worst Album at their awards show the following year), the backlash from fans as Razorlight “went commercial”, and the fist-fights between bandmates as they tussled with their newfound success and which direction they should go next. The frontman, who now lives in France, says it all feels like “300 years ago”. In the past he and the rest of the band have been on the outs – drummer Andy Burrows once claimed that working with Borrell was “hell” – but the four original members are returning to their divisive second album with an anniversary tour, a vinyl reissue of the album and a new documentary.

I ask Borrell what he remembers from that time. “I could not believe what was going on – Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, George W Bush… the Iraq War, Afghanistan.

And I thought, the military industrial machine of the United States, how could it be any worse?” he says. But no one wanted to talk to him about any of that.

In Razorlight’s vintage era, his interviews were the stuff of legend: he proclaimed himself a “genius” in his first interview with NME in 2004, while promoting Razorlight’s debut album Up All Night, then threw in the immortal line: “Dylan is making the chips, I’m drinking the champagne.” (He’s previously insisted he was regularly misquoted.)I wonder if there was any part of him that relished his status as indie’s cockiest frontman.

“Back then there wasn’t any social media, so if you wanted to communicate with your fans in any way, there was no other option,” he shrugs, possibly forgetting MySpace. “Had there been socials back then, I definitely would have stopped doing interviews in about 2005, 2006, because at times I was just furious. When people put what you’ve said across in a way that is just not what you’ve said…

that was what was infuriating, and it used to happen all the time.”open image in galleryJohnny Borrell (third from left): ‘I think the most confusing place I’ve ever been in my life is the mainstream’ (Getty Images)It’s no surprise that critics viewed Borrell as an easy target for ridicule, particularly when their second album propelled them from a modest success story – their first album hit No 3 on the charts and spawned a handful of singles, including “Golden Touch” – to a mainstream triumph (so not rock’n’roll). It debuted at No 1 in the UK and also produced their first and only No 1 single, “America”.

Critics hated the track: one branded it “soft rock hell” while others criticised what they called “faux-sentiment”, an attempt at serious political commentary from someone they believed had no right to do so. One dissenter was The Independent’s late critic, Andy Gill, who in his five-star review praised the track’s “billowing, Springsteen-esque climax” and the band’s acknowledgement of “a general sense of dissociation from the country’s cultural mores”. Borrell actually thinks it was more punk rock, in a way, to come out with Razorlight.

But fans and the media seemed to take